Internal debates: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
import>Caballo No edit summary |
RedParabola (talk | contribs) (added {{cleanup}}) |
||
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{Cleanup|date=April 2024|reason=too narrow a focus and almost incomprehensible}} | ||
== Internal debates on the Soviet Union == | |||
{| class="sortable" | {| class="sortable" | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Tendency !! Year of political degeneration in Russia !! Year of capitalist restoration/installation in Russia !! Cause of Russia degeneration and subsequent restoration !! USSR's political economy (circa 1933) !! Vanguardism !! Organisational form !! Parliamentary participation !! National liberation !! Trade unions | ! Tendency !! Year of political degeneration in Russia !! Year of capitalist restoration/installation in Russia !! Cause of Russia degeneration and subsequent restoration !! USSR's political economy (circa 1933) !! Vanguardism !! Organisational form !! Parliamentary participation !! National liberation !! Trade unions | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Anarchism]] || 1917 or 1918 || N/A or 1917 or 1918 || Bourgeois | | [[Anarchism]] || 1917 or 1918 || N/A or 1917 or 1918 || [[Bourgeois revolution]], Authoritarianism || State-capitalism or state-socialism || No || Federalism || Abstentionism || No || Strategic(tactical) | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Impossibilism]] || 1917 or 1918 || N/A || Bourgeois | | [[Impossibilism]] || 1917 or 1918 || N/A || Bourgeois revolution || Capitalism || No || Direct democracy || Strategic or principled || No || ? | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[ | | [[Dengism]]<ref group="Note">Self-declared Marxist–Leninists who ideologically align with the modern [[Communist Party of China]]. </ref>|| ~1953 or ~1985 || around 1990 || Lack of market reforms, foreign pressures || Socialism || N/A || N/A || N/A || Yes (claimed) || N/A | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Left Communism]] || 1918 to early 1920s || N/A || Failure to expand to other countries, Counter-revolution || Capitalism || Yes | | [[Left Communism]] || 1918 to early 1920s || N/A || Failure to expand to other countries, Counter-revolution || Capitalism || Yes ([[Bordigism|Italian Left]]) | ||
No ([[Council Communism|Dutch-German Left]]) | |||
| Organic centralism (Italian Left) | |||
Direct Democracy | |||
(D-G Left) || Abstentionism || No || Varied, often no | |||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Neo-Kautskyists]] || 1918 to early 1920s || 1990 || Socially non-viable economy || Non-mode of production || No || Democracy || Tactical || ? || Tactical | | [[Neo-Kautskyists]] || 1918 to early 1920s || 1990 || Socially non-viable economy || Non-mode of production || No || Democracy || Tactical || ? || Tactical | ||
Line 17: | Line 23: | ||
| [[Trotskyism]] || 1926 || around 1990 || Socialism in One Country || Degenerated Workers' State (state-capitalism) || Yes || Democratic centralism || Yes || Yes || Strategic | | [[Trotskyism]] || 1926 || around 1990 || Socialism in One Country || Degenerated Workers' State (state-capitalism) || Yes || Democratic centralism || Yes || Yes || Strategic | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Anti- | | [[Anti-revisionism]]<ref group="Note">Refers to [[Hoxha]]-aligned Marxist–Leninist([[Marxism–Leninism–Stalinism|-Stalinists]]).</ref>|| 1953<ref group="Note">Death of [[Stalin]] and rise of revisionist elements under [[Khrushchev]]. </ref>|| 1956<ref group="Note">[[De-stalinization|Destalinization]], dismantlement of the [[dictatorship of the proletariat]], and large-scale market reforms. </ref>|| Revisionism || Socialism || Yes || Democratic centralism || Varied; often strategic || Yes || Strategic | ||
|- | |||
|[[Maoism]] | |||
|1953 | |||
|1956 | |||
|Revisionism, supposed lack of "mass line" | |||
|Socialism | |||
|Yes | |||
|Democratic | |||
centralism (claimed) | |||
|Mostly | |||
Abstentionism | |||
<ref group="Note">Maoists aligned with political line of the [[Shining Path|Communist Party of Peru (Shining Path)]] follow strict anti-electorialism. However, certain Maoists, such as those in [[Nepal]], believe in reformist and multi-party principles. </ref> | |||
|Yes | |||
|No | |||
|- | |||
|[[Eurocommunism|Euro-communism]] | |||
|1920s | |||
|N/A | |||
|Authoritarianism, revolutionism | |||
|Capitalism | |||
|No | |||
|Democracy | |||
|Yes | |||
|No | |||
|Yes | |||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Council communism]] || N/A || N/A || Bourgeois revolution || State-capitalism || No || Federalism || Abstentionism || No || Strategic (tactical) | | [[Council communism]] || N/A || N/A || Bourgeois revolution || State-capitalism || No || Federalism || Abstentionism || No || Strategic (tactical) | ||
|} | |} | ||
==Internal debates on the People's Republic of China== | |||
[[Category:Issues]] | [[Category:Issues]] | ||
{| class="sortable" | |||
|- | |||
!Tendency!!Year of political degeneration in China!!Year of capitalist restoration/installation in China!!Cause of China degeneration and subsequent restoration!!PRC's political economy (circa 1975) !!Vanguardism!!Organisational form!!Parliamentary participation!!National liberation!!Trade unions | |||
|- | |||
|[[Anarchism]]||1949||N/A or 1978||[[Bourgeois revolution]], Authoritarianism||State-capitalism or state-socialism||No||Federalism||Abstentionism||No||Strategic(tactical) | |||
|- | |||
|[[Impossibilism]]||1949||N/A||Bourgeois revolution||Capitalism||No||Direct democracy||Strategic or principled||No|| ? | |||
|- | |||
| [[Dengism]]|| N/A<ref name=":0" group="Note">Rejects the notion that the [[People's Republic of China]] ever became revisionist and (re-)implemented capitalism. </ref>|| N/A<ref name=":0" group="Note" />|| N/A<ref name=":0" group="Note" />|| Socialism || N/A || N/A || N/A || Yes (claimed) || N/A | |||
|- | |||
|[[Left Communism]]||1949||N/A||Failure to expand to other countries, Counter-revolution||Capitalism||Yes ([[Bordigism|Italian Left]]) | |||
No ([[Council Communism|Dutch-German Left]]) | |||
|Organic centralism or centralism||Abstentionism||No||Varied, often no | |||
|- | |||
|[[Anti-revisionism]]||1949<ref group="Note">Most anti-revisionists maintain that [[Mao Zedong]] and the CPC always upheld deviationist and revisionist views.</ref>||N/A or 1978||Revisionism|| Capitalism ||Yes||Democratic centralism ||Strategic or principled ||Yes||Strategic | |||
|- | |||
|[[Maoism]] | |||
|1976<ref group="Note">Death of Mao Zedong, [[Gang of Four]] arrested, and end of the [[Cultural Revolution]].</ref> | |||
|1978<ref group="Note">Conclusive political consolidation of [[Deng Xiaoping]], beginning of mass-privatization. </ref> | |||
|Revisionism | |||
|Socialism | |||
|Yes | |||
|Democratic | |||
centralism (claimed) | |||
|Abstentionism | |||
|Yes | |||
|No | |||
|- | |||
|[[Eurocommunism|Euro-communism]] | |||
|1949 | |||
|N/A | |||
|Authoritarianism, revolutionism | |||
|Capitalism | |||
|No | |||
|Democracy | |||
|Yes | |||
|No | |||
| Yes | |||
|- | |||
|[[Council communism]]|| N/A||N/A||Bourgeois revolution||State-capitalism||No||Federalism||Abstentionism||No||Strategic (tactical) | |||
|} | |||
== Notes == | |||
<references group="Note" /> |
Latest revision as of 18:11, 2 April 2024
This article may require cleanup to meet Leftypedia's quality standards. The specific problem is: too narrow a focus and almost incomprehensible.(April 2024) |
Internal debates on the Soviet Union
Tendency | Year of political degeneration in Russia | Year of capitalist restoration/installation in Russia | Cause of Russia degeneration and subsequent restoration | USSR's political economy (circa 1933) | Vanguardism | Organisational form | Parliamentary participation | National liberation | Trade unions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anarchism | 1917 or 1918 | N/A or 1917 or 1918 | Bourgeois revolution, Authoritarianism | State-capitalism or state-socialism | No | Federalism | Abstentionism | No | Strategic(tactical) |
Impossibilism | 1917 or 1918 | N/A | Bourgeois revolution | Capitalism | No | Direct democracy | Strategic or principled | No | ? |
Dengism[Note 1] | ~1953 or ~1985 | around 1990 | Lack of market reforms, foreign pressures | Socialism | N/A | N/A | N/A | Yes (claimed) | N/A |
Left Communism | 1918 to early 1920s | N/A | Failure to expand to other countries, Counter-revolution | Capitalism | Yes (Italian Left)
No (Dutch-German Left) |
Organic centralism (Italian Left)
Direct Democracy (D-G Left) || Abstentionism || No || Varied, often no | |||
Neo-Kautskyists | 1918 to early 1920s | 1990 | Socially non-viable economy | Non-mode of production | No | Democracy | Tactical | ? | Tactical |
Trotskyism | 1926 | around 1990 | Socialism in One Country | Degenerated Workers' State (state-capitalism) | Yes | Democratic centralism | Yes | Yes | Strategic |
Anti-revisionism[Note 2] | 1953[Note 3] | 1956[Note 4] | Revisionism | Socialism | Yes | Democratic centralism | Varied; often strategic | Yes | Strategic |
Maoism | 1953 | 1956 | Revisionism, supposed lack of "mass line" | Socialism | Yes | Democratic
centralism (claimed) |
Mostly
Abstentionism [Note 5] |
Yes | No |
Euro-communism | 1920s | N/A | Authoritarianism, revolutionism | Capitalism | No | Democracy | Yes | No | Yes |
Council communism | N/A | N/A | Bourgeois revolution | State-capitalism | No | Federalism | Abstentionism | No | Strategic (tactical) |
Internal debates on the People's Republic of China
Tendency | Year of political degeneration in China | Year of capitalist restoration/installation in China | Cause of China degeneration and subsequent restoration | PRC's political economy (circa 1975) | Vanguardism | Organisational form | Parliamentary participation | National liberation | Trade unions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anarchism | 1949 | N/A or 1978 | Bourgeois revolution, Authoritarianism | State-capitalism or state-socialism | No | Federalism | Abstentionism | No | Strategic(tactical) |
Impossibilism | 1949 | N/A | Bourgeois revolution | Capitalism | No | Direct democracy | Strategic or principled | No | ? |
Dengism | N/A[Note 6] | N/A[Note 6] | N/A[Note 6] | Socialism | N/A | N/A | N/A | Yes (claimed) | N/A |
Left Communism | 1949 | N/A | Failure to expand to other countries, Counter-revolution | Capitalism | Yes (Italian Left)
No (Dutch-German Left) |
Organic centralism or centralism | Abstentionism | No | Varied, often no |
Anti-revisionism | 1949[Note 7] | N/A or 1978 | Revisionism | Capitalism | Yes | Democratic centralism | Strategic or principled | Yes | Strategic |
Maoism | 1976[Note 8] | 1978[Note 9] | Revisionism | Socialism | Yes | Democratic
centralism (claimed) |
Abstentionism | Yes | No |
Euro-communism | 1949 | N/A | Authoritarianism, revolutionism | Capitalism | No | Democracy | Yes | No | Yes |
Council communism | N/A | N/A | Bourgeois revolution | State-capitalism | No | Federalism | Abstentionism | No | Strategic (tactical) |
Notes
- ↑ Self-declared Marxist–Leninists who ideologically align with the modern Communist Party of China.
- ↑ Refers to Hoxha-aligned Marxist–Leninist(-Stalinists).
- ↑ Death of Stalin and rise of revisionist elements under Khrushchev.
- ↑ Destalinization, dismantlement of the dictatorship of the proletariat, and large-scale market reforms.
- ↑ Maoists aligned with political line of the Communist Party of Peru (Shining Path) follow strict anti-electorialism. However, certain Maoists, such as those in Nepal, believe in reformist and multi-party principles.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Rejects the notion that the People's Republic of China ever became revisionist and (re-)implemented capitalism.
- ↑ Most anti-revisionists maintain that Mao Zedong and the CPC always upheld deviationist and revisionist views.
- ↑ Death of Mao Zedong, Gang of Four arrested, and end of the Cultural Revolution.
- ↑ Conclusive political consolidation of Deng Xiaoping, beginning of mass-privatization.